Illustration: an older parent at home with a caregiver

Agency or private hire?

A licensed home care agency employs the aide, handles payroll and insurance, screens and trains staff, and sends a substitute when someone is sick. A private hire usually costs less per hour, and you choose the person, but your family takes on the employer's jobs. Many families start with an agency and move to a private hire for a caregiver they already know, or the reverse. Compare: HOMEWARD vs a home care agency.

Taxes: you are probably an employer

A caregiver who works in your parent's home on your schedule is usually a household employee, not a contractor. For 2026, if you pay one household employee $3,000 or more in cash wages during the year, Social Security and Medicare taxes apply to all of those wages, and you file Schedule H with your federal return (IRS Publication 926). New York has its own household employer rules for withholding and unemployment insurance (NYS Tax Department). A household payroll service or accountant can set this up.

Wages and hours

For 2026, the minimum wage in the rest of New York State outside New York City, Long Island and Westchester is $16.00 an hour (New York State). New York's Domestic Workers' Bill of Rights also sets overtime and rest-day rules for domestic workers (NYS DOL). Market rates for experienced aides are usually higher than minimum wage; CareScout's 2025 New York median for home care is $35 an hour, which reflects agency pricing.

Insurance New York requires

  • Workers' compensation: required when a domestic worker works 40 or more hours a week for the same employer (NYSIF).
  • Disability and paid family leave: required for a domestic worker employed 20 or more hours a week (NY Workers' Compensation Board).
  • Check your homeowner's policy too; some cover household workers and some do not.

Screening and a written agreement

  • Check references from two recent families and verify any certifications.
  • Consider a background check, with the candidate's written consent.
  • Put duties, hours, pay, time off, and what happens if your parent is hospitalized in a written agreement.
  • Keep a backup plan for sick days and vacations.
  • Never give a new caregiver control of bank accounts; keep bill paying with family.

If your parent has Medicaid

Through CDPAP, a Medicaid member can choose their own aide, including many relatives other than a spouse, and the state's fiscal intermediary handles payroll. See Medicaid home care in New York.

Common questions

Do I have to pay taxes for a private caregiver in 2026?

Usually yes. If you pay one household employee $3,000 or more in cash wages in 2026, Social Security and Medicare taxes apply and you file Schedule H. New York has its own household employer rules too.

What is the minimum wage for a caregiver in Buffalo in 2026?

$16.00 an hour, the 2026 rate for New York outside New York City, Long Island and Westchester.

Do I need workers' compensation for a private caregiver in New York?

Yes, if the caregiver works 40 or more hours a week for you. Disability and paid family leave coverage is required at 20 or more hours a week.

Next step

Not sure what your parent needs yet? Take the free two-minute HOMEWARD Snapshot or book a free 15-minute call. You can also call (716) 300-2769. HOMEWARD serves Erie and Niagara counties.

Related: How to pay for home care in New York · Home care costs in Buffalo · HOMEWARD vs a home care agency · Medicaid home care in New York

Get a call back from our team

Tell us a little about your parent and we will call you back to talk through next steps. Serving Erie & Niagara Counties.

Prefer to talk now? Call (716) 300-2769. Not for emergencies: call 911.